| Indianapolis |
| Passing: | Peyton Manning 20/31 (166 YDS) |
| Rushing: | Dominic Rhodes 20 CAR (84 YDS) |
| Receiving: | Brandon Stokley 5 REC (57 YDS) |
|
| Tennessee |
| Passing: | Vince Young 10/21 (63 YDS) |
| Rushing: | Travis Henry 19 CAR (123 YDS) |
| Receiving: | Brandon Jones 3 REC (40 YDS) |