| Cleveland |
| Passing: | Derek Anderson 16/26 (110 YDS) |
| Rushing: | Jamal Lewis 24 CAR (77 YDS) |
| Receiving: | Braylon Edwards 2 REC (36 YDS) |
|
| Indianapolis |
| Passing: | Peyton Manning 15/21 (125 YDS) |
| Rushing: | Joseph Addai 15 CAR (57 YDS) |
| Receiving: | Reggie Wayne 4 REC (46 YDS) |