| Miami |
| Passing: | Chad Pennington 22/33 (183 YDS) |
| Rushing: | Ronnie Brown 24 CAR (136 YDS) |
| Receiving: | Ted Ginn Jr. 11 REC (108 YDS) |
|
| Indianapolis |
| Passing: | Peyton Manning 14/23 (303 YDS) |
| Rushing: | Joseph Addai 6 CAR (32 YDS) |
| Receiving: | Dallas Clark 7 REC (183 YDS) |